top of page
Spring 2026 menu (2).png

MOCKTAILS

TAMPA VICE

Cinnamon coconut cream, pineapple, grenadine | $8

NO-GRONI

Non-alcoholic gin, non-alcoholic red bitter

FAUX AMARETTO SOUR

CHAMOMILE MARGARITA

Non-alcoholic amaretto, lemon, demerara I $8

Chamomile tea, orange, agave, lime
Try it with a salt rim!

Milk Punch

Clarified milk punch is a cocktail with origins dating back to 18th century England. It's made by curdling milk in a punch, which binds particles together so they can be strained out, resulting in a clear, rich, and smoothing drink without the heaviness of dairy.

Sounds good but trust us! It's soooo delicious.

Rotating flavors - try it before it's gone!

SOLD OUT - New Flavor Coming Soon!

"Pickleback" Duo

NEW!

Take it like a shot or sip them together and savor - introducing the Pickleback Duo - crafted to bring you a new, rotating flavor combination.

SPRING EDITION: Coconut Washed Grand Optimist Bourbon x Pickled Strawberry Brine. 1 oz each | $14

classics $13

VODKA

CARRIE BRADSHAW

Halcyon Days Cranberry Vodka, Cointreau, lime, simple syrup

VODKA SOUR

Starling Vodka, lemon, simple syrup, Falernum

COLD BREW MARTINI

Starling Vodka, cold brew, Mr. Black coffee liqueur, vanilla liqueur, simple syrup
Or try it with Willow's Oatmeal Cream Pie Bourbon

GIN

LAVENDER BEES KNEES

Elysian Fields Lavender Gin, lemon, honey, elderflower liqueur, orange blossom water

WHISKEY

PAPER PLANE

Grand Optimist Bourbon Whiskey, Cappelletti, Amaro Nonino, lemon

WHISKEY SOUR

Grand Optimist Bourbon Whiskey, simple syrup, lemon, bitters

OLD FASHIONED

Grand Optimist Bourbon Whiskey, demerara sugar, bitters
Or try it with Willow's Oatmeal Cream Pie Bourbon or our Rye Whiskey
Try it smoked +$1

EMPIRE MANHATTAN

Grand Optimist Empire Rye, vermouth, bitters

AGAVE

LAVENDER PALOMA

Vida Morada Lavender Agave Spirit, grapefruit juice, lime, soda water

LAVENDER MARGARITA

Vida Morada Lavender Agave Spirit, lime juice, agave, cointreau

MARTINIS $13

TRADITIONAL

Choice of spirit with dry vermouth and lemon twist

DIRTY

Starling Vodka or Golden Hour Dry Gin

mules

BETTER MULE

Starling Vodka, Lime, Fever Tree Ginger Beer | $10

EMPIRE MULE

Grand Optimist Empire Rye, lemon,  Fever Tree Ginger Beer | $12

canned cocktails

SPARKLING LAVENDER LEMONADE

with Elysian Fields Lavender Gin 8.4% | $8

CRANBERRY MULE

with Halcyon Days Cranberry Vodka 8.4% | $8

*Bring home a 4 pack of canned cocktails for $16.99!

gin & Tonics

GOLDEN HOUR & TONIC

Golden Hour Dry Gin, Fever Tree Tonic | $10
Light Tonic available for substitution 

ELYSIAN & TONIC

Elysian Fields Lavender Gin, Fever Tree Elderflower Tonic | $10

YUZU  & TONIC

Moonstruck Gin, Mediterranean Tonic | $10
*Approved by international hip hop star 50 Cent*

NEGRONIS

TONY NEGRONI

Golden Hour Dry Gin, Cappelletti, Antica Formula vermouth | $14

LAVENDER NEGRONI

Elysian Fields Lavender Gin, rose infused Dolin Blanc, Lillet Blanc, Italicus, peychauds bitters | $14  

OLD PAL

Grand Optimist Rye Whiskey, Cappelletti, dry vermouth  | $14

BOULEVARDIER

Grand Optimist Bourbon Whiskey, Inferno, Antica Formula vermouth  | $14

Grand-Optimist-BOURBON-Pattern-01.jpg

GRAND OPTIMIST WHISKIES

BOURBON WHISKEY 

Distiller's Cut | 2oz | $12

MALTO BENE AMERICAN WHISKEY

Distiller's Cut | 2oz | $12

GRAND OPTIMIST WHEATED BOURBON

Distiller's Cut | 2oz | $12

GRAND OPTIMIST EMPIRE RYE WHISKEY

Distiller's Cut | 2oz | $12

FLIGHT BOARDS

WHEN YOU JUST CAN'T CHOOSE

GIN + TONIC FLIGHT BOARD  $15

Pick 3: served in 1oz pours with a side of ice, tonic, and citrus to DIY your own G&T! 

GOLDEN HOUR DRY GIN

ELYSIAN FIELDS LAVENDER GIN

MOONSTRUCK YUZU GIN

RED HORIZON APPLE GIN

WHISKEY TASTING FLIGHT BOARD     $22

Pick 3: served in 1oz pours with a side of ice, for you enjoy neat or on the rocks

GRAND OPTIMIST BOURBON WHISKEY

EMPIRE RYE WHISKEY

GRAND OPTIMIST WHEATED BOURBON

MALTO BENE SINGLE MALT WHISKEY

FRANKENSTEIN (SEASONAL - WHILE SUPPLIES LAST)

canned beer

Talea Brew Co. I Dry Citra IPA | 6% | $9 

FRESH COAST

​

RYE GUY

Spider Bite Beer Co. | Rye IPA | 6.5% | $9 

LIGHT & TIGHT

Sunday Beer I Lager | 3.9% | $6 (12oz) 

QUESTIONS ASKED BY ANCIENT SEEDS

Uber Geek | "Chicha Morada" Peruvian Refresher | 5.1% | $9 

JUICED

Sand City Brewing Co. | Mixed Berry Sour | 7.0% | $9 

TAP beer

LEAD JAMMER IPA

Two Havens Brewing | IPA 7.2% I $9

ALTO

Twin Forks Brewing  | Hazy NEIPA 6.5% I $9

NON-ALCOHOLIC

SUBTLE TEA $3.75

Sweetless
Sweet
Peach
Teamonade
Raspberry
Honey Green
Lemonade

SPIRITS

*Only to be purchased and brought home - not for consumption on premises. 

vodka

STARLING VODKA

750 mL | $29.99

​

HALCYON DAYS CRANBERRY VODKA

750 mL | $32.99

375 mL | $19.99

gin

GOLDEN HOUR DRY GIN

750 mL | $39.99

 

ELYSIAN FIELDS LAVENDER GIN

750 mL | $45.99

375 mL | $24.99

 

RED HORIZON APPLE FORWARD GIN

750 mL | $45.99

375 mL | $24.99

 

MOONSTRUCK CITRUS GIN

750 mL | $45.99

375 mL | $24.99

​

BARREL RESTED NEGRONI

375 mL | $25.99

​

​

READY TO DRINK

SPARKLING LAVENDER LEMONADE

4 PACK | $16.99

​

CRANBERRY MULE

4 PACK | $16.99

​

BARREL AGED NEGRONI

375mL | $25.99

​

whiskey

GRAND OPTIMIST WHEATED

BOURBON WHISKEY

DISTILLER'S CUT

750 mL | $65.99

​

GRAND OPTIMIST BOURBON WHISKEY

DISTILLER'S CUT

750 mL | $55.99

​

GRAND OPTIMIST

EMPIRE RYE WHISKEY

750 mL | $65.99

*Tabs cannot be split more than 4 ways

​

WIFI

Betterman Guest

cosmicsoul2023

TASTING ROOM HOURS
MONDAY/TUESDAY/WEDNESDAY: CLOSED

THURSDAY: 5-10PM

FRIDAY: 5-10PM

SATURDAY: 1-10PM

SUNDAY: 12-7PM​

BOTTLE SHOP HOURS
MONDAY/TUESDAY/WEDNESDAY: CLOSED

THURSDAY: 5-8PM

FRIDAY: 5-9PM

SATURDAY: 3-9PM

SUNDAY: 1-6PM​

WHT_Betterman_Icon_SQUARE.png
161 River Ave, Patchogue, NY 
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page